Renwicks at Macdonald Cardrona Hotel, Golf and Spa

We were staying at the hotel and booked to eat on the first night. The welcome at the restaurant was lovely and got a great seat by the window. The service by everyone was perfect. Really friendly and welcoming. I had the steak and it was cooked to perfection. One of the best I have had. Cooked and tasted much better than some steak restaurants! Would definitely recommend the restaurant.

Food was lovely but service pretty poor. Food felt rushed while drinks very slow. Not a lot of atmosphere.

Food was okay, felt like every dish had been prepared at 8am that morning. No outstanding dish, plus all the kids food was so unhealthy! Everything came with chips, no vegetables even offered! Overall we won’t return!

Dinner was ok. Breakfast limited but good.

The first meal I had was very good and I thoroughly enjoyed my beef followed by Sticky Toffee pudding. The second night it was the same menu and I decided to have the Burger and Chips - I was a little disappointed when I received a small roll with a slice of red onion,then burger with a slice of tomato and a small piece of lettuce. It was advertised as with salad but I didn't call what I got was classed as a salad. Nevertheless it was quite enjoyable. I was disappointed the menu didn't include chicken as it is always a good alternative. Overall, the food was very good and the service was very good.

Excellent service in Restaurant. On the first night the waitress was on her own, greeting us taking orders and serving, and despite this we were not kept waiting. Praise to her and she should have had help which was the case on the second night. The only comment was that the menu was virtually the same on both evenings.

We enjoyed our meal and the food was to a good standard. However, the fact that you can only order a minimum of two courses for £30 I find atrocious. I understand the need for limited choice but customers should not be forced into two courses that are so overpriced. I will not be returning.

Dinner was perfect the first night and service great. Breakfast first morning excellent. Second morning ,what happened! Wait too long. no juice or butter, with hot bread. Half cup of coffee and tea. Staff under pressure due to staff shortage.

We ate here while staying in the hotel. The tables are socially distributed and all appropriate measures in place. The menu was really good and all dishes were delicious! The service was excellent especially the restaurant manager who was exceptional! Thoroughly enjoyable experience.

We stayed 2 nights at this hotel and the menu was the same on both nights with only one veggie choice. They did do something else for me, but the sauce was the same as the day before and it wasn’t to my taste. A glass of wine ranged for £6.60 to £12 for a 175 ml glass. My partner loved the food!